APECS Future Questioned Costly Acrimonious Summit

WITH Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin absent and leaders unable even to agree a joint statement, some critics are questioning whether the annual APEC summit is still worth the effort.

“The entire world is worried,” was the grim warning from Papua New Guinea Prime Minister Peter O’Neill at the end of the summit.

He was referring to tensions between the US and China exposed during the weekend’s meeting.

It was the first time leaders had failed to agree on a declaration in 29 years of the Pacific Rim summits that involve countries representing 60 per cent of the world economy.

The failure did not come as a surprise to everyone.

“Expectations are low and probably won’t be fulfilled anyway.” That was the brutal if prescient pre-summit prediction of William Reinsch, an analyst at the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

The two-day gathering in Papua New Guinea was almost five years in the making, cost untold millions of US dollars and required the deployment of at least one battleship and three cruise liners.

And after all that, leaders came away with little more than three family photos and a loud shirt unlikely to be worn again.

The grouping was born three decades ago as a way of promoting trade liberalisation. But that cause has fallen out of vogue and Port Moresby was little more than a different venue for another China-US bunfight.

For the first time ever, the leaders failed to produce a joint summit declaration – usually a technocratic exercise in fudging differences, overstating agreement and promising great things to come.

It is likely to be a disappointment for host Papua New Guinea, which was making its debut on the international stage – at no insignificant cost.

Prime Minister Peter O’Neill’s government – not much larger than a municipal authority in most developed countries – visibly struggled with hosting such an enormous enterprise.

It dealt with more than 21 delegations, each numbering in the dozens if not hundreds who needed to be fed, housed and watered and ferried around a city not exactly designed for armour plated motorcades.

Papua New Guinea officials forgot to provide lighting for a leaders’ photo opportunity, outside, at night and at another they put their own flag upside down.

They also suffered enormous pressure from much more powerful countries. Chinese officials on one occasion reportedly demanded that hundreds of red flags for Xi Jinping’s state visit be kept up.

In another instance, the police had to be called to prevent officials from Beijing storming the foreign minister’s office. China denies the incident.

But the summit’s failure was hardly the fault of rookie stagecraft. Skipping the leaders’ scheduled coffee break on the last day wasn’t going to provide enough time to sort through the defining strategic rivalry of our time.

“I feel sorry for Papua New Guinea, this was their big show’ said Euan Graham, executive director of La Trobe Asia, describing a diplomatic minnow caught in the crossfire of the world’s two largest economic and military powers.

Papua New Guinea did benefit from the rivalry and chequebook diplomacy of the two powers, winning new investments in energy, electricity and infrastructure.

O’Neill, like other small power leaders, also got images of himself mixing with global big hitters.

Executive director of the APEC secretariat, Alan Bollard said the organisation was about more than the annual shindig.

“APEC is more than just a leaders’ meeting, but a place for economies to incubate ideas throughout the year,” he told AFP.

US officials hope that next year will bring Trump’s return, but it may matter little if protectionist and nationalistic trends persist and the United States and China continue butting heads.

“APEC’s founding vision was already fraying,” said Graham. “But the failure to agree a communique is a final death knell for a pan-Asia-Pacific trade framework.”

About Vanuatu: An Overview of Population Trends and Landscape Features

Nestled in the South Pacific, Vanuatu stands as a diverse island nation with a rich cultural tapestry. The Republic of Vanuatu consists of approximately 83 islands with a population that ...

Planning Your Stay in Vanuatu: A Friendly Guide to Paradise Island Accommodations

Dreaming of a tropical getaway that's still off the beaten path? Vanuatu might be just what you're looking for. This island nation in the South Pacific offers pristine beaches, active ...

Things to Do in Vanuatu: Exploring the South Pacific Paradise

Vanuatu offers travelers a unique blend of natural wonders and cultural experiences across its jungle-covered islands. From swimming in pristine blue lagoons to exploring active volcanoes, this South Pacific nation ...

Vanuatu Cuisine: Essential Dishes and Flavors of the South Pacific

Nestled in the South Pacific, Vanuatu's cuisine tells a story of island abundance and cultural fusion. This Melanesian nation's food reflects its rich heritage, with the Ni-Vanuatu people crafting dishes ...

Vanuatu History: Unveiling the Ancient Pacific Legacy

Vanuatu, a stunning archipelago in the South Pacific Ocean, has a rich history dating back over 4,000 years. Originally known as the New Hebrides, this island nation was jointly ruled ...

Vanuatu Islands: A Complete Guide to the South Pacific’s Hidden Paradise

Nestled in the southwestern Pacific Ocean, Vanuatu is a captivating archipelago consisting of over 80 islands, with 65 being inhabited. Located about 1,750 kilometers east of northern Australia and 540 ...

Vanuatu Provinces: A Comprehensive Guide to the Island Nation’s Administrative Divisions

Vanuatu, a beautiful Pacific island nation, is organized into six distinct provinces that help govern this archipelago of volcanic origin. These provinces - Torba, Sanma, Penama, Malampa, Shefa, and Tafea ...

Where to Stay in Vanuatu: Best Hotels, BnBs, Vacation Homes, and More!

Planning a trip to Vanuatu means choosing between stunning islands, each with its own unique charm. This South Pacific paradise offers everything from luxurious beachfront resorts to budget-friendly accommodations that ...
Scroll to Top